People often say the “law needs to always catch up with technology”. While this statement holds true considering it from the perspective of regulating technologies, with current technological advancements happening, we must also consider its use in the domain of law. Such advancements are creating unprecedented opportunities coupled with significant challenges. I have studied [and followed] the intersection of law and technology since the first semester of my law school [the year 2015], and I can, without a doubt, say that I have seen progression on both sides- technology and the law. This interplay between technology and the law becomes increasingly vital as we look ahead, and the dynamic relationship will determine how society harnesses trustworthy technological innovations while safeguarding ethical standards, privacy, security, and fairness. In this brief article, I would endeavour to leave the readers with a fundamental understanding of the challenges around technology and law, discuss some mainstream technologies and their challenges, and leave them with food for thought regarding future regulation.
The Evolution of Technology and Legal Frameworks
The evolution of technology at an extraordinary rate often outpaces the ability of legal frameworks to remain in sync. Modern-day technologies such as artificial intelligence [hereinafter, “AI”], blockchain, the Internet of Things [hereinafter, “IoT”], etc., are pushing the boundaries of what is possible, bringing forth new ethical dilemmas, privacy concerns, and security risks that current legal frameworks may not adequately address.
The traditional legislative process tends to be slow, deliberative, and reactive, while technology is fast, disruptive, and proactive. This mismatch has so far led to creating regulatory potholes and gray areas, where new technologies operate without clear guidelines or oversight. As we move forward, legal frameworks must become more agile, adaptive, and forward-thinking to bridge this gap.
Artificial Intelligence
I have already written a wealth of pieces [including a book] concerning artificial intelligence, a technology at the forefront of technological innovation fuelling the Industrial Revolution 4.0. With applications spanning healthcare, finance, transportation, entertainment, etc., these technologies have the potential to revolutionise industries, but they also raise significant legal and ethical issues.
Accountability is a primary concern arising from using AI and its deployment. AI systems today make decisions impacting individuals' lives, such as loan approvals, job screenings, or medical diagnoses. When these systems make mistakes or exhibit bias, determining liability becomes complex. Current legal frameworks often struggle to assign responsibility when an algorithm's decision leads to harm.
Moreover, AI systems can perpetuate and amplify existing biases in the data on which they are trained. Ensuring fairness and transparency in AI decision-making processes is a legal and ethical imperative. This calls for robust regulations that mandate explainability, accountability, and regular audits of AI systems to detect and mitigate biases. The European Union, so far, has shown tremendous advancements [and intent!] in regulating AI. I think that similar to the General Data Protection Regulation [hereinafter, “GDPR”] that became a standard for data protection laws that followed worldwide; the Artificial Intelligence Act will be equally promising from the perspective of governing artificial intelligence.
Data Privacy and Protection
Data has become a valuable commodity in the digital age, driving innovation and economic growth. However, personal data collection, storage, and use have raised significant privacy concerns, especially when advanced artificial intelligence systems used for building new-age technological tools are being trained using them. High-profile data breaches and scandals involving misuse of personal information have heightened public awareness and demand for stronger privacy protections.
The GDPR represented a significant step forward in data privacy legislation, setting stringent standards for data protection and giving individuals greater control over their personal information. Similar initiatives are emerging globally, reflecting a growing recognition of the need to protect individuals' privacy rights. India’s enactment of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, which I think would be more challenging to comply with than the GDPR, is also a step in the right direction. But what is equally important to understand is that we initiate such processes so that future regulations and technological advancements become easier [and ethical]. We must also be mindful not to simply follow the frameworks of different countries, as each country has unique challenges and objectives when developing a framework or policy for regulation.
As technology advances, new challenges will emerge. For example, the proliferation of IoT devices creates vast amounts of data, often collected without users' explicit consent. Hence, an enormous challenge is for the legislators to address how to protect privacy in an increasingly connected world, ensuring that individuals retain control over their data while not compromising innovation.
Image credits - Spiceworks
Cybersecurity
Cybersecurity has become a paramount concern with the increasing reliance on digital infrastructure. Cyberattacks, ranging from data breaches to ransomware, can have devastating consequences for individuals, businesses, and governments. As cyber threats evolve in sophistication and scale, so must the legal response.
Existing cybersecurity laws often focus on post-incident responses, such as breach notification requirements and penalties for failing to protect data. While these measures are important, they may not be sufficient to prevent attacks in the first place. Modern legal frameworks should emphasise proactive measures, such as mandatory security standards, regular security assessments and audits, and information sharing between public and private sectors to improve overall resilience.
Moreover, the international nature of cyber threats necessitates global cooperation. Cybersecurity is not confined to a nation’s borders, and isolated national efforts are insufficient to address it effectively. International treaties and agreements that facilitate collaboration, information exchange, and coordinated responses to cyber threats will be crucial in the future.
Blockchain
With its decentralised and immutable nature, blockchain technology has the potential to revolutionise various sectors, including finance, supply chain management, and healthcare. However, it also presents unique legal challenges.
One critical legal issue surrounding blockchain is the question of jurisdiction. Blockchain transactions can occur across borders, involving parties from different legal jurisdictions. Determining which laws apply and how to enforce them becomes complex in a decentralised environment.
Additionally, blockchain's immutability, while a strength in ensuring data integrity, can pose challenges for compliance with regulations such as the GDPR, which grants individuals the right to have their data erased. Balancing the benefits of blockchain with compliance requirements will require innovative legal solutions.
Legal Technology
As technology advances, the legal profession itself is transforming. Legal technology, which encompasses the use of technology to enhance legal processes and services, is revolutionising how legal work is accomplished.
AI-powered legal research tools, contract analysis software, intellectual property infringement detection tools, and virtual courtrooms are examples of how technology streamlines legal processes and improves access to justice. These innovations can reduce costs, increase efficiency, and enhance the quality of legal services.
However, adopting legal tech also raises important ethical and regulatory considerations. Ensuring the reliability and accuracy of AI-powered legal tools, protecting client confidentiality, and addressing the potential for bias in automated decision-making are critical challenges that must be addressed. I have discussed the barriers to the adoption of legal technology in India in one of my opinion pieces published in The New Indian Express. Readers can refer to this article for a better understanding of this issue.
Image credits - The Mint
What's the future of technology regulation?
The regulation of emerging technologies will require a multifaceted approach that balances innovation with ethical considerations and public interest. Policymakers must adopt flexible and adaptive regulatory frameworks to keep pace with technological advancements while protecting fundamental rights and values. In some cases, stringent regulation may be required, but in others, we may adopt a soft-law approach.
Another crucial intervention for shaping effective technology regulation is public engagement and stakeholder collaboration. As technology continues to impact various aspects of society, involving diverse voices, including technologists, academics, ethicists, legal experts, and affected communities, will help ensure that regulations are comprehensive and inclusive.
Moreover, regulatory sandboxes, which allow for controlled experimentation and testing of new technologies in a real-world environment, can provide valuable insights and inform the development of effective regulations. Regulatory sandboxes can help bridge the gap between technology and the law by fostering a culture of innovation and responsible experimentation.
Conclusion
The future of technology and its relationship with the law is as dynamic as the field itself. As technological innovations continue to shape our world, the legal frameworks that govern them must evolve in tandem. Balancing the benefits of technological advancements with ethical considerations, privacy protection, and security is a complex but essential task.
By fostering adaptive, forward-thinking legal frameworks and promoting collaboration between stakeholders, we can navigate the challenges and opportunities presented by emerging technologies. In doing so, we can ensure that technology serves the greater good, enhances human well-being, and upholds the fundamental values of our society. The interplay between technology and the law will be a defining feature of the 21st century, and its successful navigation will determine the trajectory of our technological future, which must ideally be based on trust, ethics, security, and responsible innovation.
Mr Nikhil Naren (he/him) is a British Chevening Scholar, an Assistant Professor at the Jindal Global Law School, and Of Counsel at Scriboard, New Delhi. His research focuses on the intersection of law, technology, and society. Nikhil regularly contributes to leading national dailies and scholarly platforms and has co-authored two books on this subject.
Website - https://nikhilnaren.in/
Linkedin- @Nikhil Naren Twitter - @Nikhilnaren31 Instagram - @nikhilnaren.in
Commentaires